Frequently Asked Questions

At PrintMTG, our goal is not to make exact replicas, but rather to make high-quality close-match proxies that are convincing when sleeved. We don’t add holo stamps, for example. Instead they are printed from our scans.

While Proxy King specializes in exact replicas, recreated by their design team, PrintMTG takes a different approach. We utilize high-resolution scans and printing onto top-notch card stock.

We ensure that each proxy matches the original cards’ size and weight. Although these proxies might lack holographic stamps and the texture may slightly differ from original Magic cards, they’re incredibly convincing when sleeved and perfect for casual play around the kitchen table.

The benefit of our approach is that we can offer virtually any card, at a low price.

With our MTG proxy printing service, you can print almost any card ever produced. It may take some time to get brand new releases into our database.

If you are trying to get a specific print that isn’t coming up in our tool, reach out and we will see if we can make it.

Our MTG proxy printing service allows you to input an entire deck and have it printed on demand.

In addition, you can upload your own designs or make them with our online card design tools.

Our service has a great advantage over other proxy sites due to our ability to offer virtually any MTG card ever made – at an unbeatable price point, complete with quantity discounts.

We have created high quality MTG card templates that allow you to completely design and customize unique Magic the Gathering cards. Our easy onling editor let’s you edit text, images, symbols, and more to make each card completely unique. Just check out our MTG Card Maker to get started.

Yes! With our MTG card printing service, you can paste in an entire deck list for printing. 

No, you can print a single card if you want. And if you order higher quantities, you can save money with our quantity price breaks. 

Yes we can. We will be rolling it out on our site soon. In the meantime, you can reach out if you want custom foil printing, it is a bit more expensive than standard card printing.

Because every PrintMTG order is custom-printed to your specifications, we do not accept standard “changed my mind” returns. Instead, our policy is simple: if something arrives with a verified defect or we made an error, we’ll make it right (typically via reprint, replacement, or credit depending on the situation).

Cancellations (Before Printing Begins)
If you need to cancel an order, email [email protected] as soon as possible. We often begin production quickly—sometimes within hours—so cancellations are only possible before printing starts.

Wrong Item / Incorrect Order
If you receive the wrong item, wrong quantity, or wrong variation, contact us right away. We’ll correct the mistake and get the right items to you.

Print Defects / Damage / Quality Issues
If your order arrives with a print defect, a cutting issue that materially affects the product, or damage from shipping, please email us
with your order number and clear photos (including packaging if it was damaged in transit). Once we confirm the issue, we’ll resolve it—typically with a reprint or replacement, and in some cases credit or another fair solution.

Not satisfied? Talk to us.

If something feels off, reach out. The fastest way for us to help is: order number + a brief description + photos.

We typically produce orders within 2 business days (Mon–Fri), and many are produced the same or next business day. During peak periods or for custom/large orders, production time may extend.

Shipping time depends on your location and the method you choose.

For USPS Standard Shipping within the United States, transit time is typically 3–7 business days after your order ships (about 5–9 business days total including production).

If you need your cards faster, we also offer UPS 2nd Day Air and UPS Next Day Air. These are calculated at checkout (typically around $15.50 and $36.00).

If you need your cards by a specific date, reach out before ordering and we’ll help you choose the best option.